Partners and Programs:
  • BARS
  • SKYbrary
  • ASN
  • Contact Us
  • Members' Center
  • Login
  • Support Aviation Safety

  • Industry Updates
  • The Foundation
    • About the Foundation
    • Asia Pacific Centre for Aviation Safety
    • Founders
    • Mission
    • History
    • Leadership
    • Officers and Staff
    • Media/Communications
    • Aviation Award & Scholarship Programs
    • Work with Us
    • Join Us
  • AeroSafety World
  • Events
  • Toolkits & Resources
    • Mental Health and Wellness
    • Global Action Plan for the Prevention of Runway Incursions (GAPPRI)
    • COVID-19 Crisis Resources
    • Fatigue Management
    • Flight Path Monitoring
    • Global Action Plan for the Prevention of Runway Excursions (GAPPRE)
    • Go-Around Project
    • Global Safety Assessment Project
    • Learning From All Operations
    • Past Safety Initiatives
    • Pilot Training and Competency
    • Special Reports
    • ASN Accident Dashboards
    • ASN Accident Data
    • Videos
  • Industry Updates
  • The Foundation
    • About the Foundation
    • Asia Pacific Centre for Aviation Safety
    • Founders
    • Mission
    • History
    • Leadership
    • Officers and Staff
    • Media/Communications
    • Aviation Award & Scholarship Programs
    • Work with Us
    • Join Us
  • AeroSafety World
  • Events
  • Toolkits & Resources
    • Mental Health and Wellness
    • Global Action Plan for the Prevention of Runway Incursions (GAPPRI)
    • COVID-19 Crisis Resources
    • Fatigue Management
    • Flight Path Monitoring
    • Global Action Plan for the Prevention of Runway Excursions (GAPPRE)
    • Go-Around Project
    • Global Safety Assessment Project
    • Learning From All Operations
    • Past Safety Initiatives
    • Pilot Training and Competency
    • Special Reports
    • ASN Accident Dashboards
    • ASN Accident Data
    • Videos
  • Contact Us
  • Members' Center
  • Login
  • Support Aviation Safety
Partners and Programs:
  • BARS
  • SKYbrary
  • ASN

FLIGHT SAFETY FOUNDATION HEADQUARTERS

701 N. Fairfax Street, Suite 250,
Alexandria, Virginia 22314

Phone: +1 703 739 6700 Fax: +1 703 739 6708

  • Aviation Safety Experts
  • Industry Updates
  • New Final Report Issued on Ditching That Led to Review of ATSB Methods

News, Accident Investigation

New Final Report Issued on Ditching That Led to Review of ATSB Methods

by FSF Editorial Staff | November 28, 2017

The Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) has issued a final report on its reopened investigation of the Nov. 18, 2009, ditching of an Israel Aircraft Industries Westwind 1124A — five years after the original report and four years after the initial investigation prompted a request for a review by the Transportation Safety Board of Canada (TSB) of ATSB procedures.

The emergency medical services flight from Apia, Samoa, was headed to Norfolk Island — a self-governing Australian territory in the Pacific Ocean — for refueling. Low clouds obscured the runway, and after several missed approaches, the crew ditched the airplane. All six occupants were rescued by boat; two suffered serious injuries.
In its original final report on the ditching, released in 2012, the ATSB said that the flight crew’s preflight and en route planning was incomplete and that their late assessment of landing conditions left them a choice of making another approach at night in deteriorating weather conditions or ditching before fuel was depleted.

Australian lawmakers criticized those conclusions, and a Senate committee said the ATSB had “repeatedly deflected suggestions that significant deficiencies with both the operator … and [the Australian Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA)] … contributed to the accident.”

In 2015, the TSB’s review identified problems including poor data collection that hindered the ATSB’s analysis of several safety issues, among them crew fatigue, fuel management, and company and regulatory oversight.
The Norfolk Island investigation was reopened in late 2014 and the new final report, issued last week, included a focus on the TSB’s comments. The report said the captain’s preflight planning “did not include many of the elements needed to reduce the risk of a long-distance flight to a remote island,” including his decision to leave Apia without the maximum fuel load.

Neither the operator nor the regulator had specific fuel planning requirements for passenger flights to remote islands, the report said.

After the accident, CASA modified requirements, including fuel requirements, for operations to remote islands and strengthened its surveillance processes, the report said.

The report said that the “most fundamental lesson” of the new investigation “is to recognise that unforecast weather can occur at any aerodrome. Consequently, there is a need for robust and conservative fuel planning and in-flight fuel management procedures for passenger-transport flights to remote islands and isolated aerodromes.”

Share:

Print:

Key Safety Issues

  • Controlled Flight Into Terrain (CFIT)
  • Loss of Control–In Flight (LOC-I)
  • Mechanical Issues
  • Runway Safety (approach and landing)
  • Sabotage/Intentional Acts
  • Midair Collisions (MAC)
  • Runway Safety (Conflicts)
  • Wildlife Issues
  • Fatigue
  • Cabin Safety
  • Emerging Safety Issues
    • Lithium Batteries
    • Safety Information Sharing and Protection
    • Unmanned Aircraft Systems

Related Content

News, Accident/Incident Investigation, Safety Recommendation

ATSB Seeks Better Design Tolerance to Dual Control Inputs

The European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and aircraft manufacturer ATR should act to improve…

by FSF Editorial Staff

DataLink

Surge in Fatalities

Despite a near-doubling of Australian aviation fatalities in 2017, data show no deaths in RPT…

by Linda Werfelman

News, Flight Ops

ATSB Data: 417 Turboprops With Engine Problems in 5 Years

Nearly 1,900 occurrences involving technical failures on turboprop aircraft were reported to the Australian Transport…

by FSF Editorial Staff

Read more articles

1920 Ballenger Ave., 4th Floor, Alexandria, VA 22314

Phone: +1 703 739 6700 Fax: +1 703 739 6708

Projects & Partners

  • Basic Aviation Risk Standard
  • SKYbrary
  • Aviation Safety Network
  • Asia Pacific Centre for Aviation Safety
  • Donate
  • Advertise on our website
  • Sponsor & Exhibit at our Events
  • Work with Us
  • Contact Us
  • Site Map
  • Privacy

© 2025 Flight Safety Foundation

Join our group on LinkedIn